Attentionality and Lines of Life in the Poopó-Uru-Qotzuñi Meshwork (“People of Water”)
No. 34 (2019-01-01)Author(s)
-
Koen de Munter
-
Felipe Trujillo
-
Ruth Carol Rocha Grimoldi
Abstract
Objective/Context: An anthropological reflection on the consequences of the desertification of Lake Poopó, in Bolivia, particularly for the Uru-Qotzuñi group “people of water” from an approach that is conceived as an anthropology of life. The article studies the way in which quotidian and ritual practices allow a “human correspondence” with the lake and its inhabitants, thus weaving a meshwork of Poopó-Uru-Qotzuñi life. Methodology: A series of anthropological approaches were used for the analysis, leading us to think about life in a broad and relational sense, whose clues are particularly evident in the recent work of Tim Ingold, but also in other social-ecological references such as Anna Tsing and Donna Haraway´s work, allowing us, based on these proposals, to learn together with the Uru of Poopó about attention and how to live with responsibility, responsiveness and correspondence. In order to do this the text is structured on the basis of the outcomes obtained through an ethnographic work and interdisciplinary collaboration sustained over time with local institutions dedicated to defending the lake. Conclusions: What is at stake, we argue, is not only water availability, nor a set of cultural practices simply associated with the lake, but the very survival of this whole meshwork of life, in a broad and relational sense. This, because from the vantage point of an anthropology of life, survival always presupposes a coexistence in reciprocity that ought to be thought - even in its political and legal dimensions - in terms of attentionality. Originality: The analysis proposed here is relevant, first, because it is a case that is not usually studied from an anthropological perspective, and second because the research expressed here aims not only to inform ethnographically about a specific social ecological context but also to propose a critical and attentive look at the life processes that accompany it, deploying, in the process, a series of contemporary and creative anthropological theoretical explorations and proposals.
References
Arias Carballo, Julián.2015. Una Organización Social en Defensa de la Madre Tierra.Oruro: Coridup-CEPA.
Astvaldsson, Astvaldur.2000. Las Voces de los wak’a: Fuentes Principales del Poder Político Aymara. Serie Jesús de Machaqa: La Marka Rebelde. La Paz: Cipca.
Berchin, Issa Ibrahim, Isabela Blasi Valduga, Jéssica Garcia, y JoséBaltazar Salgueirinho Osório de Andrade Guerra. 2017. “Climate Change and Forced Migrations: An Effort towards Recognizing Climate Refugees”. Geoforum 84: 147-50.
Carey, Mark, Michel Baraer, Bryan G. Mark, Adam French, Jeffrey Bury, KennethR. Young, y JeffreyM. McKenzie. 2014. “Towards Hydro-Social Modeling: Merging Human Variables and the Social Sciences with Climate-Glacier Runoff Models (Santa River, Peru)”. Journal of Hydrology 518: 60-70.
Choque Churata, Calixta y AlisonSpedding. 2009. Culto a los uywiris. Comunicación ritual en Anchallani. La Paz: Iseat-Editorial Mama Huaco.
Conde, Marta.2017. “Resistance to Mining. A Review”. Ecological Economics 132: 80-90.
Condori, Santiago y GilbertoPauwels.1996. “Un angelito de Dios: los Chipayas y la naturaleza”. Eco Andino 1: 23-39.
Cresswell, Tim.2010. “Towards a Politics of Mobility. Environment and Planning”. Society and Space 28 (1): 17-31.
Crevels, Emily Irene y PieterMuysken, eds. 2009. Lenguas de Bolivia. La Paz: Plural Editores.
De Munter, Koen, JacquelineMichaux y GilbertoPauwels, eds. 2017. Ecología y Reciprocidad: “(con)vivir bien” desde contextos andinos. La Paz: Plural-URAL-CEPA-TARI.
De Munter, Koen.2018. “Leren door aandacht: doden bezoeken en gedenken, bij de Aymara en in de Lage Landen”. Volkskunde119 (1): 25-45.
De Munter, Koen.2016. “Ontología relacional y cosmopraxis, desde los Andes: Visitar y conmemorar entre familias Aymara”. Chungará. Revista de Antropología Chilena 48 (4): 629-64.
De Munter, Koen.2007. Nayra. Ojos al sur del presente: aproximaciones antropológicas a la interculturalidad contemporánea. Oruro: Latinas Editores-CEPA.
Diaz-Cuellar, Vladimir.2017. “The Political Economy of Mining in Bolivia during the Government of the Movement Towards Socialism (2006–2015)”. The Extractive Industries and Society 4 (1): 120-30.
Escobar, Arturo.2014. Sentipensar con la tierra: nuevas lecturas sobre desarrollo, territorio y diferencia.Medellín: Ediciones Unaula.
Farber, Jessica.2016. “Social Isolation and Climate Change: An Inextricable Bind”. McGwill University Research Papers, disponible en: http://www.socialconnectedness.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/03/Jessica-Farber-Social-Isolation-and-Climate-Change-An-Inextricable-Bind.pdf
Flores, Apolinar.2017. “Tierra-Territorio, alternativa de sobrevivencia para los pueblos urus del lago Poopó”. En Ecología y reciprocidad: “(con)vivir bien” desde contextos andinos, editado por Koen deMunter, JacquelineMichaux y GilbertoPauwels. La Paz: Plural-URAL-CEPA-TARI.
Gutiérrez Villca, Delia.2014. Caza y Pesca. Razón de existencia Uru. Cochabamba: Funproeib CENU.
Haraway, Donna J.2016. Staying with the Trouble: Making Kin in the Chtulucene. Durham: Duke University Press Books.
Ingold, Tim.2018c. Anthropology. Why it Matters. Nueva York: Wiley books.
Ingold, Tim.2018b. Anthropology and/as Education. Londres: Routledge.
Ingold, Tim.2018a. La vida de las líneas. Santiago: Ediciones Universidad Alberto Hurtado.
Ingold, Tim.2016. “From Science to Art and Back again: The Pendulum of an Anthropologist”. Anuac 5 (1): 5-23.
Lave, Jean.1991. “Situating Learning in Communities of Practice”. Perspectives on Socially Shared Cognition 2: 63-82.
Martinez-Alier, Javier, 2009. “Social Metabolism, Ecological Distribution Conflicts, and Languages of Valuation”. Capitalism Nature Socialism 20: 58–87.
Martinez-Alier, Javier.2003. The Environmentalism of the Poor: A Study of Ecological Conflicts and Valuation.Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing.
Perreault, Tom.2015. “Performing Participation: Mining, Power, and the Limits of Public Consultation in Bolivia: Mining, Power, and the Limits of Public Consultation in Bolivia”. The Journal of Latin American and Caribbean Anthropology 20 (3): 433-451.
Posnansky, Arthur.1949. “Los Urus”. Recorte de prensa, Bolivia: La Paz.
Schneider, Martin y MarkusVogt.2017. “Responsible Resilience: Rekonstruktion der Normativität von Resilienz auf Basis einer Responsiven Ethik”. GAIA-Ecological Perspectives for Science and Society 26/S1.
Viaene, Lieselotte.2013. “La relevancia local de procesos de justicia transicional. Voces de sobrevivientes indígenas sobre justicia y reconciliación en Guatemala posconflicto.” Antípoda. Revista de Antropología y Arqueología 16: 85-112.
Wachtel, Nathan.1978. “Hommes d’eau: le probléme Uru -Xviéme Et Xviiéme siécle”. Annales, Economies, Sociétés et Civilisation 33 (5-6): 1126-1159.
Whitt, Clayton.2017. “Dying and Drying: The Case of Bolivia´s Lake Poopó”. En NACLA, edición 30 de junio, disponible en: https://nacla.org/news/2017/06/30/dying-and-dryingcase-bolivia%E2%80%99s-lake-poop%C3%
Yampara, Simón.2016. Suma Qama Qamaña. Paradigma Cosmo-Biótico Tiwanakuta Crítica al Sistema Mercantil Kapitalista. El Alto. Edición Qamañ Pacha.