A century of constitution-making in Latin America: an inclusiveness-based comparative analysis (1917-2016)
No. 6 (2021-02-01)Author(s)
-
Cristián EyzaguirreUniversity of Chicago Law School, Comparative Constitutions Project (United States) Gobierno de Chile, Ministerio Secretaría General de la Presidencia, División Jurídico-Legislativa (Chile)
-
Ventura CharlinPrincipal, V.C. Consultants (Chile)
Abstract
Inclusiveness has been increasingly recognized as one of the key elements that shape the outcome of a constitution-making process (CMP). This article surveys all the CMPs in Latin America from 1917 to 2016 to determine their level of inclusiveness. A novel aspect of this study is that it distinguishes between two types of inclusiveness, procedural and effective. Therefore, it provides a more in-depth assessment of the degree of inclusiveness during the CMPs. We found that although most CMPs can be described as procedurally inclusive, only a few of them met minimal democratic conditions; consequently, most CMPs could not be described as effectively inclusive. On the other hand, we also identified a relationship between higher procedural inclusiveness and higher democratic conditions. Lastly, we noticed that both procedural inclusiveness and democratic conditions have gradually risen through the years, especially in the last three decades.
References
Becker, Marc. “Ecuador: Correa, indigenous movements, and the writing of a new constitution.” In Rethinking Latin American social movements: radical action from below, edited by RichardStahler-Sholk, HarryVanden and MarcBecker, 267-283. Lanham: Rowman and Littlefield Publishers, 2014.
Bellegarde-Smith, Patrick. Haiti: The Breached Citadel. Toronto: Canadian Scholars Press Inc, 2004.
Blount, Justin, ZacharyElkins, and TomGinsburg. “Does the process of constitution-making matter?” In Comparative constitutional design, edited by TomGinsburg, 31-65. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2012.
Bruneau, Thomas. “Government and politics.” In Paraguay: a country study, edited by DennisHanratty and SandraMeditz, 157-199. Washington, D.C.: Federal Research Division, Library of Congress, 1990.
Carrillo, Tomás. Cuentas nacionales de Venezuela: 1915-1935. Caracas: Banco Central de Venezuela, 2003.
Coppedge, Michael, JohnGerring, CarlHenrik Knutsen, Staffan I.Lindberg, Svend-ErikSkaaning, JanTeorell, DavidAltman, MichaelBernhard, AgnesCornell, M. StevenFish, HaakonGjerløw, AdamGlynn, AllenHicken, JoshuaKrusell, AnnaLührmann, Kyle L.Marquardt, KellyMcMann, ValeriyaMechkova, MoaOlin, PamelaPaxton, DanielPemstein, BrigitteSeim, RachelSigman, JeffreyStaton, AkselSundtröm, EitanTzelgov, LucaUberti, Yi-tingWang, ToreWig, and DanielZiblatt. “V-Dem Codebook v8”. Varieties of Democracy Project, Gothenburg, 2018.
Coppedge, Michael, JohnGerring, CarlHenrik Knutsen, Staffan I.Lindberg, Svend-ErikSkaaning, JanTeorell, JoshuaKrusell, Kyle L.Marquardt, JurajMedzihorsky, DanielPemstein, JosefinePernes, NataliaStepanova, EitanTzelgov, Yi-tingWang, and StevenWilson. “V-Dem Methodology v8” Varieties of Democracy Project, Gothenburg, 2018.
Corrales, Javier. Fixing democracy: why constitutional change often fails to enhance democracy in Latin America. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2018.
De Galíndez, Jesús. “Dominican Republic: new constitution.” The American Journal of Comparative Law 5, n° 2 (1956): 271-273.
Eisenstadt, Todd, CarlLeVan, and TofighMaboudi. Constituents before assembly: participation, deliberation, and representation in the crafting of new constitutions. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2017.
Elkins, Zachary, TomGinsburg and JamesMelton. The endurance of national constitutions. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2009.
García Guadilla, María Pilar and MónicaHurtado. “Participation and constitution making in Colombia and Venezuela: enlarging the scope of democracy?” Latin American Studies Association, Miami, 2000.
Ghai, Yash. “The role of constituent assemblies in constitution making.” International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance, Stockholm, 2006.
Guzmán, Teodoro. “El procedimiento de reforma, la participación popular y las reformas de la Constitución en Cuba (1959-2002).” Estudios Constitucionales 13, n° 2 (2015): 237-272.
Huneeus, Carlos. El régimen de Pinochet. Santiago: Taurus, 2016.
Huntington, Samuel. The third wave: democratization in the late twentieth century. Oklahoma: University of Oklahoma Press, 1993.
Klein, Marcus. “Our Brazil will awake! The Acção Integralista Brasileira and the failed quest for a fascist order in the 1930s.” Center for Latin American Research and Documentation, Amsterdam, 2004.
Lehoucq, Fabrice and AníbalPérez-Liñán, “Breaking out of the coup trap: political competition and military coups in Latin America.” Comparative Political Studies 47, n.° 8 (2014): 1105-1129, https://doi.org/10.1177/0010414013488561.
Lindberg, Staffan. “Ordinal versions of V-Dem’s indices: when interval measures are not useful for classification, description, and sequencing analysis purposes.” Geopolitics, History and International Relations 8, n.° 2 (2016): 76-111.
Negretto, Gabriel. Making constitutions: presidents, parties, and institutional choice in Latin America. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2013.
Negretto, Gabriel. “Procesos constituyentes y refundación democrática. El caso de Chile en perspective comparada”. Revista de Ciencia Política 35, n.° 1 (2015): 201-215, http://dx.doi.org/10.4067/S0718-090X2015000100010.
Negretto, Gabriel. “Constitution making and constitutionalism in Latin America: the role of procedural rules.” In Comparative constitutional law in Latin America, edited by RosalindDixon and TomGinsburg, 17-56. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing, 2017.
Ríos, Marcela, ValentinaSalas, NicolásBenkel and SebastiánMadrid and. “Mecanismos de cambio constitucional en el mundo: análisis desde la experiencia comparada”. Programa de lasNaciones Unidas para el Desarrollo, Vitacura, 2015.
Rosenn, Keith. “Brazil’s new constitution: an exercise in transient constitutionalism for a transitional society.” The American Journal of Comparative Law 38, n.° 4 (1990): 773-802, https://repository.law.miami.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1165&context=fac_articles.
Saati, Abrak. “The participation myth: outcomes of participatory constitution building processes on democracy.” Doctoral thesis, Umeå University, 2015.
Samuels, Kirsti. “Constitution building processes and democratization: a discussion of twelve case studies.” International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance, Geneva, 2006.
Tushnet, Mark. Advanced introduction to comparative constitutional law. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing, 2014.
Widner, Jennifer. “Constitution writing and conflict resolution.” United Nations University World Institute for Development Economics Research, Helsinki, 2005.
License
Copyright (c) 2021 Cristián Eyzaguirre, Ventura Charlin
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.