Dearq

Dearq | eISSN 2215-969X

Recreate What Has Never Been Created. The Double Paradox of Reconstructing the Formworks of the "House in Jean Mermoz" (1956-1961-1992)

No. 39 (2024-05-31)
https://doi.org/10.18389/dearq39.2024.03

Abstract

Thirty years after its demolition, the House in Jean Mermoz (Fabio Cruz Prieto, 1956-1961), a foundational work of the Valparaíso School, regains substance thanks to a design investigation with the aim of recovering the invaluable experience of being on site. However, what was recreated in 2021 was not strictly a replica but rather what was never seen of the house: the formwork system of the concrete structure. In light of the paradox of replacement by Heraclitus and Plato, and Aristotle's causes, two referential cases are analyzed—the Ise Shrine (7th century) and the Barcelona Pavilion (1929). This raises the need for a fifth cause; the contextual one. Finally, the article presents a critical reflection on the case of the recreation of the House in Jean Mermoz within the issue of architectural reconstructions.

Keywords: House in Jean Mermoz, Aristotelian causes, Escuela de Valparaíso, paradox of replacement, reconstruction

References

Aristóteles. 2003. "Las cuatro causas y la filosofía anterior". En Metafísica. Traducido por Tomás Calvo Martínez. Madrid: Gredos.

Borges, Jorge Luis. 1996. "Pierre Menard, autor del Quijote". En Ficciones. Buenos Aires: Emecé editores.

Cruz Prieto, Fabio. 2012. Construcción Formal (2003). Valparaíso: Ediciones e[ad], 2a ed.

Cruz Prieto, Fabio. 2015. Casa en Jean Mermoz. Carta memoria del año 1960. Valparaíso: Ediciones e[ad].

Fracalossi, Igor. 2018. Volver a la cercanía. Casa en Jean Mermoz (1956-1961-1992) (Tesis doctoral, Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile).

García Yebra, Valentín, ed. 1999. Poética de Aristóteles. Madrid: Gredos.

Jaque, Andrés. 2015. "Mies in the Basement: The Ordinary Confronts the Exceptional in the Barcelona Pavilions". Thresholds (43): 120-278. https://doi.org/10.1162/thld_a_00062

Leich, Neil. 2001. La an-estética de la arquitectura. Barcelona: Gustavo Gili.

Macken, Marian. 2009. "Solidifying the Shadow: Post Factum Documentation and the Design Process". Architectural Theory Review, 14 (3): 333-343. https://doi.org/10.1080/13264820903341688

Martínez de Arbulo, Alejandro. 2023. "The Ship of Theseus: a misleading paradox? The authenticity of wooden built heritage in Japanese conservation practice". Journal of Architectural Conservation, 29 (2): 151-167. https://doi.org/10.1080/13556207.2022.2160554

Nietzsche, Friedrich. 2013. El libro del filósofo. Madrid: Taurus, 2.a ed.

Pérez de Arce, Rodrigo y Fernando Pérez Oyarzun. 2003. Escuela de Valparaíso: Grupo Ciudad Abierta. Santiago de Chile: Contrapunto.

Pérez Oyarzun, Fernando. 1993. "The Valparaiso School". The Harvard Architecture Review (9): 82-101.